The History of the Challenge Coin
Some versions of history say that challenge coins began as far back as Roman times, with coins issued as identifying markers for troops. According to the most common account, however, challenge coins originated during World War I among American flying squadron volunteers. In one unit, a wealthy lieutenant presented his fellow pilots with medallions struck in solid bronze.
One young pilot placed his medallion in a small leather pouch worn around his neck. Shortly after, his aircraft was severely damaged by ground fire and he was forced to land behind enemy lines. Captured by a German patrol, he was stripped of all identification—except for the pouch around his neck.
During a night bombardment, the pilot escaped into a small French town dressed in civilian clothes. When he encountered a French outpost, his lack of identification and American accent led his captors to mistake him for a saboteur. As execution drew near, the pilot presented his bronze medallion. A French soldier recognized the squadron insignia, halted the execution, and offered him a bottle of wine.
Upon returning to his squadron, it became tradition for members to carry their medallions at all times. To enforce this, members created a challenge: if challenged, anyone unable to produce their medallion bought a drink; if they produced it, the challenger bought instead.